Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Subscription or Fee Access

FORENSIC SPORTS ANALYTICS: DETECTING AND PREDICTING MATCH-FIXING IN TENNIS

Ryan Rodenberg, Elihu D. Feustel

Abstract


Despite some degree of lingering friction between sports leagues and wagering, the eradication of corruption in sports is one issue in which the interests of sports governing bodies, reputable gambling businesses, entities affiliated with the sports industry, and law enforcement are allied.  This paper aims to: (i) detect match-fixing corruption in tennis and (ii) predict such match-fixing before it occurs.  We first compare proxy measures of effort in fair matches versus possibly unfair matches – matches played in the first round, where wagering-induced manipulation is more likely.  The results show that players exert less effort (tanking) in the first round, even when adjusting for the slightly greater difference in skill level in such matches.  We next determine whether the gambling markets were able to identify fixing, tanking, or other types of manipulation before the match was played.  Using two predictive tennis models (ELO, Common-Opponent) to determine the fair trading price of a tennis match, we find prima facie evidence of the betting markets being affected, with an average of 23 matches per year likely being manipulated or outright fixed each year.  Finally, we determine whether fixed matches can be identified before they are played using predictive modeling and by observing real-time market price changes.  We conclude that when the betting price has a large irrational move away from the fair model-predicted price, the move is indicative of a fixed match before it is played. 


Keywords


Forensic Economics; Wagering; Match-Fixing; Tennis

Full Text:

PDF

References


N Amdur ‘Lendl: Doing Things His Way’ (4 January 1982) New York Times.

P Andreoli-Versbach ‘Not Everything That Hurts, Hurts: Evidence of Cheating in Tennis’ (2012) working paper.

J Arnesen ‘41 Tennis Names on the Black List’ (19 October 2011) SvD Sport.

S Assael ‘Questions Surround Wayne Odesnik’ (26 June 2013) http://espn.go.com/tennis/wimbledon13/story/_/id/9427242/wimbledon-questions-surround-wayne-odesnik.

S Assael ‘Who is Martin Fuhrer and Why Does He Make the Tennis World So Nervous?’ (10 February 2008) ESPN Magazine

-88.

ATP World Tour ‘Rankings FAQ’ (2013) http://www.atpworldtour.com/Rankings/Rankings-FAQ.aspx.

P Bag and B Saha ‘Match-Fixing under Competitive Odds’ (2011) 73 Games and Economic Behavior 318-344.

J Barr and W Weinbaum ‘Evidence Shows Something Terribly Corrupt in Infamous Match’ (7 February 2008) http://sports.espn.go.com/sports/tennis/news/story?id=3235411.

J Battista ‘A Boost for Players Who Are Far From the Top’ (19 May 2013) http://www.nytimes.com/2012/06/03/sports/tennis/grand-slam-purses-sore-point-for-players.html?_r=0.

D Bernhardt and S Heston ‘Point Shaving in College Basketball: A Cautionary Tale for Forensic Economics’ (2010) 48(1) Economic Inquiry 14-25.

G Bishop ‘Purses Are a Sore Point for Players at Majors’ (2 June 2012) http://www.nytimes.com/2012/06/03/sports/tennis/grand-slam-purses-sore-point-for-players.html?_r=0.

A Brown ‘Evidence of In-Play Insider Trading on a UK Betting Exchange’ (2008) 44(9) Applied Economics 1169-1175.

J Brown and D Minor ‘Selecting the Best? Spillover and Shadows in Elimination Tournaments’ (2011) working paper.

S Cambers ‘Ljubicic Exclusive: I Pleaded with the Bookmakers’ (3 May 2012)

http://www.thetennisspace.com/ljubicic-exclusive-i-pleaded-with-the-bookmakers/.

S Cambers ‘Tennis and Betting – a Difficult Relationship’ (19 August 2013) http://www.thetennisspace.com/tennis-and-betting-a-difficult-relationship/.

R Caruso ‘The Basic Economics of Match Fixing in Sport Tournaments’ (2009) 39(3) Economic Analysis & Policy 355-377.

W Cohan ‘Ted Forstmann’s Bad Bet’ (15 February 2011) http://features.blogs.fortune.cnn.com/2011/02/15/ted-forstmanns-bad-bet/.

M Cronin ‘Tennis has Frequently Swept Big Problems under the Rug’ (November 2007) http://www.insidetennis.com/archive/1107_dishonesty.html.

F Deford ‘All Bets are Off’ (16 August 2008) HBO Real Sports with Bryant Gumbel Episode 137.

J del Corral ‘Competitive Balance and Match Uncertainty in Grand Slam Tennis’ (2009) 10(6) Journal of Sports Economics 563-581.

J Drape ‘Lawsuit Claims ATP Knew Stars were Tied to Betting’ (19 November 2010) http://www.nytimes.com/2010/11/20/sports/tennis/20tennis.html.

J Drape ‘Report Urges Tennis Match Fixing Investigation’ (20 May 20 2008) http://www.nytimes.com/2008/05/20/sports/tennis/20tennis.html.

J Drape ‘Talk of Efforts to Fix Matches Rattles Pro Tennis’ (25 November 2007) New York Times.

C DuBois and B Heyndels ‘It’s a Different Game You Go to Watch: Competitive Balance in Men’s and Women’s Tennis (2007) 7(2) European Sport Management Quarterly 167-185.

A Duff ‘Private Doping Probes Seen Hurting Tennis as Cilic Feigns Injury’ (24 September 2013) http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-09-24/private-doping-probes-seen-hurting-tennis-as-cilic-feigns-injury.html.

M Duggan and S Levitt ‘Winning Isn’t Everything: Corruption in Sumo Wrestling’ (2002) 92(5) American Economic Review 1594-1605.

A. Elo The Rating of Chess Players (New York, Arco Publishing, 1978).

D Forrest and I McHale ‘Anyone for Tennis (Betting)?’ (2007) 13(8) The European Journal of Finance 751-768.

R Fuller ‘Chris Kermode: ATP Chairman on his Vision for Men’s Tennis’ (17 January 2014)

http://www.bbc.com/sport/0/tennis/25773438.

M Glickman and A Jones ‘Rating the Chess Rating System’ (1999) 12(2) Chance 21-28.

S. Griffin Gaming the Game (Fort Lee, New Jersey, USA, Barricade Books, 2011).

B Gunn and J Rees (May 2008) Environmental Review of Integrity in Professional Tennis.

N Harris ‘Fixing, Doping, Whistle-Blowing: Secrets Tennis Prefers Not to Discuss’ (24 June 2013) http://www.sportingintelligence.com/2013/06/24/fixing-doping-whistle-blowing-secrets-that-tennis-prefers-not-to-discuss-240601/.

R Heron and E Lie ‘What Fraction of Stock Option Grants to Top Executives Have Been Backdated or Manipulated?’ (2009) 55(4) Management Science 513-525.

D Hill The Insider’s Guide to Match-Fixing in Football (Ottowa, Ontario, Canada, Anne McDermid & Associates Ltd, 2013).

P Hruby ‘Does Tennis Have a Gambling Problem?’ (25 June 2013) http://www.sportsonearth.com/article/51670382.

L Hvattum and H Arntzen ‘Using ELO Ratings For Match Result Prediction in Association Football’ (2010) 26 International Journal of Forecasting 460-470.

D Kaplan and J Ourand ‘ESPN seeks to unseal ATP gambling info’ (6 December 2010) http://www.sportsbusinessdaily.com/Journal/Issues/2010/12/20101206/This-Weeks-Issue/ESPN-Seeks-To-Unseal-ATP-Gambling-Info.aspx.

H. Karp ‘A Tennis Gambler Looks for a Fix’ (14 May 2009) http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB124225824919117313.

W Knottenbelt, D Spanias, and A Madurska ‘A Common-Opponent Stochastic Model for Predicting the Outcome of Professional Tennis Matches’ (2012) 64 Computers and Mathematics with Applications 3820-3827.

P Lavigne and A Pattani ‘U.S. Open Random Draw Questioned’ (15 August 2011) http://espn.go.com/espn/otl/story/_/id/6850893/espn-analysis-finds-top-seeds-tennis-us-open-had-easier-draw-statistically-likely.

K Lee ‘Inside the Common-Opponent Model for Predicting the Outcome of Professional Tennis Matches’ (2013) working

paper.

S Mattsson ‘41 Tennisnamn pa den Svarta Listan’ (19 October 2011) http://www.expressen.se/sport/tennis/41-tennisnamn-pa-den-svarta-listan/.

D McClain ‘To Detect Cheating in Chess, a Professor Builds a Better Program’ (19 March 2012) http://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/20/science/a-computer-program-to-detect-possible-cheating-in-chess.html?pagewanted=all.

I McHale and A Morton ‘A Bradley-Terry Type Model for Forecasting Tennis Match Results’ (2011) 27 International Journal of Forecasting 619-630.

R Mendick ‘Wimbledon Given Watchlist of Tennis Corruption Suspects’ (11 June 2011) http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/tennis/wimbledon/8570017/Wimbledon-given-watchlist-of-tennis-corruption-suspects.html.

M Mewshaw Short Circuit: Six Months on the Men’s Professional Tennis Tour (New York, Atheneum, 1983).

L Munson ‘Big Big Bets, and a Cheerleader’s Protest’ (18 November 2010) http://m.espn.go.com/nba/story?storyId=5821704&wjb=&pg=0.

C Oddo ‘Prize Money Rises for Slams; Not So Much Elsewhere’ (28 August 2013) http://www.usatoday.com/story/sports/tennis/2013/08/28/us-open-2013-prize-money-distribution-debate/2718233/.

J Olmo, K Pilbeam, and W Pouliot ‘Detecting the Presence of Insider Trading’ (2011) 35 Journal of Banking & Finance 2820-

A O’Malley ‘Probability Formulas and Statistical Analysis in Tennis’ (2008) 4(2) Journal of Quantitative Analysis in Sports Article 15.

L Page ‘The Momentum Effect in Competitions: Field Evidence from Tennis Matches’ (2009) working paper.

K Pijetlovic ‘Facts and Statistics Indicate Fixing at the Very Top of Men’s Tennis’ (2012) Play the Game Conference Proceedings, http://www.playthegame.org/fileadmin/image/knowledgebank/Tennisdraws_Katarina_Pijetlovic.pdf.

I Preston and S Szymanski ‘Cheating in Contests’ (2003) 19 Oxford Review of Economic Policy 612-624.

S Price ‘A Billion-Dollar Racket – Betting on Tennis is a Big Business; Just Ask the Fixers (11 September 2007) http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/vault/article/magazine/MAG1107956/index.htm.

M Ramos ‘Game, Set, Match-Fixing: Will International Anti-Doping Initiatives Pave the Way for Similar Reform for Corrupt Betting in Tennis?’ (2009) 32(1) Houston Journal of International Law 201-244.

J Reade and S Akie ‘Using Forecasting to Detect Corruption in International Football’ (2013) working paper.

D Robson ‘Prize Money Distribution Roils ATP Tour” (15 March 2012) http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/SPORTS/usaedition/2012-03-15-USAEast1SptKTXT1ART_ST_U.htm.

D Robson ‘WTA Payout Distribution Leans Toward Winner-Take-All’ (17 September 2013) http://www.usatoday.com/story/sports/tennis/2013/09/17/wta-prize-money-distribution/2825259/.

R Rodenberg ‘Who Owns Real-Time Data in Sports’ (6 February 2014) http://pando.com/2014/02/06/who-owns-real-time-

sports-data/.

D Rossingh ‘French Open Prize Rise Gives Bottom Players Financial Breather’ (31 May 2012)

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-05-31/french-open-prize-rise-gives-bottom-players-financial-breather.html.

C Snider and T Youle ‘The Fix Is In: Detecting Portfolio Driven Manipulation of the LIBOR’ (2012) working paper.

U Sunde ‘Heterogeneity and Performance in Tournaments: A Test for Incentive Effects Using Professional Tennis Data’

(2009) 41 Applied Economics 3199-3208.

Tennis Integrity Unit (2013) http://www.tennisintegrityunit.com/.

J Tisparevic ‘Pay in Tennis is Ridiculously Low’ (12 June 2012) http://www.thetennisspace.com/tipsarevic-column-pay-in-

tennis-is-ridiculously-low/.

L Thomas ‘Big Bets’ (14 March 2014) http://grantland.com/features/tennis-gambling-match-fixing-indian-wells-potential/.

J Wertheim ‘Federer’s Reputation at Risk Thanks to IMG Honcho’s Recklessness’ (25 October 2010)

http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2010/writers/jon_wertheim/10/25/best.three/index.html.

J Wertheim ‘Best of Three’ (25 July 2011)

http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2011/writers/jon_wertheim/07/25/best-of-three/index.html.

J Wolfers ‘Point Shaving in College Basketball’ (2006) 96(2) American Economic Review 279-283.

D Wozniak ‘Gender Differences in a Market with Relative Performance Feedback: Professional Tennis Players (2012) 83(1) Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization 158-171.

B Wright, R Rodenberg, and J Sackmann ‘Best of N Contests: Quasi-Simpson’s Paradox in Tennis’ (2013) 13(3) International Journal of Performance Analysis in Sport 790-802.

WTA Tour ‘2013 WTA Ranking System’ (2013) http://www.wtatennis.com/rankings.

E Zitzewitz ‘Forensic Economics’ (2012) 50(3) Journal of Economic Literature 731-769.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.5750/jpm.v8i1.866

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.