Just How Serious is Insider Trading? An evaluation using thoroughbred wagering markets

Article Sidebar

Requires Subscription or Fee PDF (GBP 25)
Published: Jan 2, 2013
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5750/jgbe.v2i3.538
Keywords:
insider trading strong market efficiency wagering markets

Main Article Content

Les Coleman
Department of Finance The University of Melbourne

Abstract

This paper quantifies the extent and changes in insider trading in the Melbourne racetrack betting market using a unique, long term dataset. Wagering markets share many of the characteristics of other financial markets, and are simple, with good data and a designated endpoint. Thus they are an excellent natural laboratory to study what is probably happening in qualitatively similar conventional markets. Results of this paper provide statistically significant support for hypotheses supporting the existence and increase in level of insider trading, and suggest that around two percent of betting is by insiders.Research for this paper was supported by a grant from the Economics and Commerce faculty at the University of Melbourne, and was conducted very efficiently by Andrew Saunderson. Dr Ian O’Connor provided excellent assistance with analysis of data. I am grateful for valuable comments from the Journal’s editor and an anonymous reviewer, and from delegates to the 2004 Australasian Finance and Banking Conference where an early version of this paper was presented. All remaining errors and omissions are mine.

Article Details

Issue
Vol. 2 No. 3 (2008)
Section
Articles

References

Bird, R. and M. McCrae, 1987, Tests of the efficiency of racetrack betting using bookmaker odds, Management Science 33, 1552-1562.

Brailsford, T. J., S. A. Easton, P. K. Gray and S. F. Gray, 1995, The Efficiency of Australian Football Betting Markets, Australian Journal of Management 20, 167-195.

Bris, A., 2005, Do Insider Trading Laws Work? European Financial Management 11, 267-312.

Busche, K. and W. D. Walls, 2000, Decision Costs and Betting Market Efficiency, Rationality and Society 12, 477-492.

Cain, M., D. Law and D. A. Peel, 2001, The Incidence of Insider Trading in Betting Markets and the Gabriel and Marsden Anomaly, The Manchester School 69, 197-207.

Cain, M., D. Law and D. A. Peel, 2003, The Favourite-Longshot Bias, Bookmaker Margins and Insider Trading in a Variety of Betting Markets, Bulletin of Economic Research 55, 263-273.

Chauvin, K. W. and C. Shenoy, 2001, Stock price decreases prior to executive stock option grants, Journal of Corporate Finance 7, 753-776.

Coleman, L., 2004, New Light on the Longshot Bias, Applied Economics 36, 315-326.

Coleman, L. and M. McGrath, 2005, Biases and Insider Trading in Exotic Bets on Thoroughbreds, Published in Vaughan Williams, L. (ed), Information Efficiency in Betting Markets (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).

Cornell, B. and E. R. Sirri, 1992, The reaction of investors and stock prices to insider trading, The Journal of Finance 47, 1031-1059.

Crafts, N. F. R., 1985, Some Evidence of Insider Knowledge in Horse Race Betting in Britain, Economica 52, 295-304.

Dowie, J., 1976, On the Efficiency and Equity of Betting Markets, Economica 43, 139-150.

Eckbo, B. E. and D. C. Smith, 1998, The Conditional Performance of Insider Trades, The Journal of Finance 53, 467-498.

Fair, R. C., 2002, Events that Shook the Market, Journal of Business 75, 713-731.

Fama, E. F., 1970, Efficient Capital Markets: A review of theory and empirical work, Journal of Finance 25, 383-417.

Fama, E. F., L. Fisher, M. C. Jensen and R. Roll, 1969, The Adjustment of Stock prices to New Information, International Economic Review 10, 1-21.

Fingleton, J. and P. Waldron, 2001, Optimal Determination of Bookmakers' Betting Odds: Theory and tests. Trinity Economic Paper Series. (Trinity College, Dublin).

Friederich, S., A. Gregory, M. John and I. Tonks, 2002, Short-run Returns around the Trades of Corporate Insiders on the London Stock Exchange, European Financial Management 8, 7-30.

Gabriel, P. E. and J. R. Marsden, 1990, An Examination of Market Efficiency in British Racetrack Betting, Journal of Political Economy 98, 874-885.

Gandar, J. M., W. H. Dare, C. R. Brown and R. A. Zuber, 1998, Informed Traders and Price Variations in the Betting Market for Professional Basketball Games, The Journal of Finance 53, 385-401.

Gordon, J., 2001, The Horse Industry: Contributing to the Australian economy (Rural Industries Research and Development Corporation, Canberra)

Hillier, D. and A. P. Marshall, 2002, The Market Evaluation of Information in Directors' Trades, Journal of Business Finance & Accounting 29, 77-110.

Jayaraman, N., M. B. Frye and S. Sabherwal, 2001, Informed Trading Around Merger Announcements, The Financial Review 37, 45-74.

Johnson, J. E. V. and A. C. Bruce, 2001, Calibration of subjective probability judgements in a naturalistic setting, Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 85, 265-290.

Kaplan, M., 2002, The High Tech Trifecta, Wired Magazine 10

Law, D. and D. A. Peel, 2001, Insider Trading, Herding Behaviour and Market Plungers in the British Horse-racing Betting Market, Economica 69, 327-338.

Levitt, S. D., 2004, Why are gambling markets organised so differently from financial markets? The Economic Journal 114, 223-246.

Lopes, L. L., 1994, Psychology and Economics: Perspectives on risk, cooperation and the marketplace, Annual Review of Psychology 45, 197-227.

Meulbroek, L. K., 1992, An empirical analysis of illegal insider trading, The Journal of Finance 47, 1661-1699.

Mikhail, M. B., B. Walther, R and R. D. Willis, 2004, Do Security Analysts Exhibit Persistent Differences in Stock Picking Ability? Journal of Financial Economics 74, 67-91.

Niehaus, G. and G. Roth, 1999, Insider Trading, Equity Issues, and CEO Turnover In Firms Subject To Securities Class Action, Financial Management 28, 52-72.

Paton, D., L. Vaughan Williams and S. Fraser, 1999, Regulating Insider Trading In Betting Markets, Bulletin of Economic Research 51, 237-241.

Rafferty, M. and M. Tomljanovich, 2002, Central bank transparency and market efficiency: An economic analysis, Journal of Economics and Finance 26, 150-164.

Sauer, R. D., 1998, The Economics of Wagering Markets, Journal of Economic Literature 36, 2021-2064.

Schnytzer, A. and Y. Shilony, 1995, Inside Information in a Betting Market, Economic Journal 105, 963-971.

Seyhun, H. N., 1986, Insiders' Profits, Costs of Trading, and Market Efficiency, Journal of Financial Economics 16, 189-212.

Shin, H. S., 1993, Measuring the Incidence of Insider Trading in a Market for State-Contingent Claims, Economic Journal 103, 1141-1153.

Snyder, W. W., 1978, Horse Racing: Testing the efficient markets model, The Journal of Finance 33, 1109-1118.

Tasmanian Gaming Commission, 2003, Australian Gambling Statistics 1976-7 to 2002-3 (Tasmanian Gaming Commission, Hobart).

Terrell, D., 1997, Biases in Assessments of probabilities: New evidence from greyhound races. Accessed: 11 November 2002. http.://citeseer.nj.nec.com/terrell97biased.html.

Thaler, R. H. and W. T. Ziemba, 1988, Parimutuel Betting Markets: Racetracks and Lotteries, Journal of Economic Perspectives 2, 161-174.

Vaughan Williams, L., 2000, Can Forecasters Forecast Successfully? Evidence from UK betting markets, Journal of Forecasting 19, 505-513.

Vaughan Williams, L., 2005, Information Efficiency in Financial and Betting Markets, (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge UK).

Vaughan Williams, L. and D. Paton, 1997, Why is there a Favourite-longshot bias in British Racetrack Betting Markets? The Economic Journal 107, 150-158.

Vaughan Williams, L. and D. Paton, 1998, Why are some favourite-longshot biases positive and others negative? Applied Economics 30, 1505-1510.

Webb, G. P., 1999, Evidence of Managerial Timing: The case of exchange listings, Journal of Financial Research 22, 247-264.